Kidney-Deficiency Lower Back Pain — Master of TCM Shen Baofan’s “Bushen Zhuangyang Tongluo Tang”
56. Kidney-Deficiency Lower Back Pain — Master of TCM Shen Baofan’s “Bushen Zhuangyang Tongluo Tang”
Shen Baofan, Third-Batch Master of TCM, practiced medicine in Xinjiang for over 60 years. For elderly lower back pain he proposed the principles “tonify the Kidney first, warm and unblock as the main approach, treat root and branch together, embed unblocking in tonifying.”
Pathogenesis
Elderly lower back pain is fundamentally rooted in Kidney Yang decline. With advancing age Kidney Qi wanes; when Mingmen fire is weak the warming power fails; cold-damp pathogens invade through the deficiency, linger in the collaterals, and when Blood meets cold it congeals, eventually forming a condition of cold and stasis mutually blocking. Xinjiang is in the northwest, cold and dry; cold pathogens are heavy and turbid and easily invade the lower jiao; the elderly constitution is already weak, so after contracting pathogens the condition lingers and is hard to cure. The pathogenesis evolves from deficiency to excess; when lower back pain flares up, deficiency and excess often appear together.
Formula Composition
Composition: Yin Yang Huo (Epimedium) 10g, Ba Ji Tian (Morinda root) 10g, Gou Ji (Cibotium rhizome) 10g, Du Zhong (Eucommia bark) 10g, Niu Xi (Achyranthes) 10g, Xu Duan (Dipsacus) 10g, Wu Yao (Aucklandia) 10g, Song Jie (Pine joint) 10g, Dang Gui (Angelica) 15g
Usage: Decoct and take orally, 1 dose per day
Actions: Tonify the Kidney and strengthen Yang, disperse cold and dispel bi (painful obstruction)
Indications: Lower back pain caused by Kidney deficiency, cold-dampness, and Blood stasis
In the formula, Yin Yang Huo and Ba Ji Tian warm and tonify Kidney Yang as the sovereign; the two are pungent-warm, enter the Kidney channel, tonify the Kidney and strengthen Yang while also strengthening sinews and bones. Gou Ji, Du Zhong, Niu Xi, and Xu Duan, the four minister herbs, enter the Liver and Kidney channels specifically, strengthen the lower back and knees, and also unblock Blood; among them Niu Xi guides the medicines downward so the medicinal power reaches the lower back and knees directly, and Xu Duan mends the sinews and sets the bones while also invigorating Blood. Wu Yao warms the Kidney, dispels cold, moves Qi, and stops pain; Song Jie dispels wind-dampness from the sinews and bones; Dang Gui invigorates Blood and nourishes Blood; the three together serve as assistants. The whole formula embeds unblocking within tonifying, is warm without being drying; it secures the congenital root to treat the deficiency and drives away pathogenic factors from the collaterals to cure the bi.
| Drug Group | Medicines & Dosages | Actions |
|---|---|---|
| Warm the Kidney and Strengthen Yang | Yin Yang Huo 10g, Ba Ji Tian 10g | Tonify Kidney Yang, strengthen sinews and bones; warm Mingmen fire to treat the root |
| Strengthen the Lower Back and Bones | Gou Ji 10g, Du Zhong 10g, Niu Xi 10g, Xu Duan 10g | Tonify the Liver and Kidney, strengthen the lower back and knees; Niu Xi guides medicines downward and also invigorates Blood, Xu Duan mends sinews and sets bones |
| Disperse Cold and Unblock Collaterals | Wu Yao 10g, Song Jie 10g | Wu Yao warms the Kidney, dispels cold, moves Qi, and stops pain; Song Jie dispels wind-dampness from the sinews and bones, unblocks collaterals |
| Invigorate Blood and Nourish Blood | Dang Gui 15g | Invigorates Blood, nourishes Blood, stops pain; treats cold congealing and Blood stasis, also prevents warming-drying medicines from injuring Yin |
Dang Gui is used in a relatively large dose, taking advantage of its ability to invigorate and nourish Blood. Cold-dampness congealing for a long time inevitably causes Blood stasis; Dang Gui both invigorates and resolves stasis and nourishes Blood to moisten the collaterals, preventing warming-drying medicines from injuring Yin and depleting Blood; it is an indispensable herb in the formula.
Modifications According to Pattern
| Concurrent Pattern | Medicines to Add | Therapeutic Intent |
|---|---|---|
| Cold-dampness predominant | Add Xi Xin (Asarum) 3g, Fu Zi (Aconite) 6g (decoct first), Du Huo (Angelica pubescens) 10g, Sang Ji Sheng (Mulberry parasite) 15g, Qian Nian Jian (Homalomena rhizome) 10g | Strengthen the power to disperse cold and eliminate dampness; used for rheumatic spondylitis, ankylosing spondylitis, and lumbar muscle strain with heavy cold-dampness |
| Stasis blocking collaterals | Add Ru Xiang (Frankincense) 6g, Mo Yao (Myrrh) 6g, Ji Xue Teng (Spatholobus stem) 15g, Tao Ren (Peach Seed) 10g, Hong Hua (Safflower) 6g | Invigorate Blood, resolve stasis, unblock collaterals, stop pain; used for lumbar sprain, lumbar disc lesions, and lumbar osteophytes with stasis-predominant presentation |
| Kidney Yang severely deficient | Add Xian Mao (Curculigo rhizome) 10g, Rou Gui (Cinnamon Bark) 3g (added later), Rou Cong Rong (Cistanche) 15g, Lu Jiao Jiao (Deer Antler Glue) 10g (melted in), Gou Qi Zi (Lycium) 15g | Warm-tonify Kidney Yang, fill essence and nourish Blood; used for osteoporosis or kidney disease with Kidney Yang deficiency |
| Kidney Yin insufficiency | Remove Yin Yang Huo, Ba Ji Tian, Gou Ji, Song Jie; add Sheng Di Huang (Raw Rehmannia) 15g, Shu Di Huang (Prepared Rehmannia) 15g, Bai Shao (White Peony) 15g, Xuan Shen (Scrophularis) 12g, Shan Zhu Yu (Cornus) 10g, Ji Xue Teng (Spatholobus stem) 15g | Nourish Yin, invigorate Blood, unblock collaterals; for Yin deficiency with fire exuberance, remove warming-drying medicines to prevent injuring Yin |
Shen Baofan emphasizes combining pattern differentiation with disease differentiation. For the same lower back pain: when cold-dampness is heavy, warming and dispersing is primary; when stasis is heavy, invigorating Blood comes first; when Kidney Yang deficiency is severe, strongly tonify Mingmen; when Kidney Yin is deficient, shift to nourishing Yin. The Yin-deficiency modification is especially worth noting: the original formula leans warming-drying; using it in a Yin-deficient constitution actually helps fire and injures Yin; warming-heat medicines must be removed and replaced with Yin-nourishing ones for safety.
Summary
Bushen Zhuangyang Tongluo Tang primarily warms and tonifies Kidney Yang, while also dispersing cold, eliminating dampness, invigorating Blood, and unblocking collaterals; suitable for elderly Kidney-deficiency, cold-dampness, Blood-stasis type lower back pain, especially for cold, painful lower back and knees, worse with cold, and aversion to cold with cold limbs. The nine herbs in the formula combine tonifying and unblocking, warm without drying; contraindicated for Yin-deficiency fire exuberance or damp-heat lower back pain.
References:
[1] Shen Baofan. Experience of Shen Baofan’s Pattern Differentiation and Treatment of Elderly Lower Back Pain [J]. Clinical Research in TCM
[2] Master of TCM Shen Baofan’s Experience Formula (Lower Back Pain / Kidney-Tonifying, Yang-Strengthening, Collateral-Opening Decoction verified formula) [J]. Journal of TCM Orthopedics and Traumatology
[3] Case of patient Wang, male, age 65, first consultation 2013-08-05; see Shen Baofan’s Elderly Lower Back Pain Verified Cases
56. 腎虛腰痛—國醫大師沈寶藩·補腎壯陽通絡湯
沈寶藩,第三屆國醫大師,紮根新疆行醫六十餘年。對老年腰痛提出”補腎為先、溫通為主、標本兼治、補中寓通”的治則。
病機
老年腰痛以腎陽虛衰為本。年高腎氣漸衰,命門火衰則溫煦無力,寒溼之邪乘虛侵襲,留著經絡,血遇寒則凝,終成寒瘀交阻之候。新疆地處西北,高寒乾燥,寒邪重濁易侵下焦,老年人體質本虛,感邪後遷延難愈。病機演變由虛致實,虛實在腰痛發作時往往並見。
方藥組成
組成:淫羊藿 10g、巴戟天 10g、狗脊 10g、杜仲 10g、牛膝 10g、續斷 10g、烏藥 10g、松節 10g、當歸 15g
用法:水煎服,每日1劑
功效:補腎壯陽,散寒蠲痺
主治:腎虛寒溼血瘀引起的腰痛
方中以淫羊藿、巴戟天溫補腎陽為君,二味辛溫入腎經,補腎壯陽兼強筋骨。狗脊、杜仲、牛膝、續斷四味為臣,專入肝腎,強腰膝而兼通血脈,其中牛膝引藥下行,使藥力直達腰膝,續斷續筋接骨兼活血。烏藥溫腎散寒、行氣止痛,松節祛筋骨間風溼,當歸活血養血,三味共為佐助。全方補中有通,溫而不燥,既固先天之本以治其虛,又逐經絡之邪以療其痺。
| 藥組 | 藥物劑量 | 功用 |
|---|---|---|
| 溫腎壯陽 | 淫羊藿 10g、巴戟天 10g | 補腎陽、強筋骨,溫命門之火以治本 |
| 強腰健骨 | 狗脊 10g、杜仲 10g、牛膝 10g、續斷 10g | 補益肝腎,強健腰膝,牛膝引藥下行兼活血,續斷續筋接骨 |
| 散寒通絡 | 烏藥 10g、松節 10g | 烏藥溫腎散寒行氣止痛,松節祛筋骨間風溼通絡 |
| 活血養血 | 當歸 15g | 活血養血止痛,治寒凝血瘀,兼防溫燥傷陰 |
當歸用量偏重,取其活血養血之能。寒溼凝滯日久必致血瘀,當歸既活血化瘀,又養血濡絡,防溫燥之品傷陰耗血,是方中不可或缺的一味。
隨證加減
| 兼證 | 加減藥物 | 立法用意 |
|---|---|---|
| 寒溼偏重 | 加細辛 3g、附子 6g(先煎)、獨活 10g、桑寄生 15g、千年健 10g | 增強散寒祛溼之力,用於風溼性脊柱炎、強直性脊柱炎、腰肌勞損寒溼重者 |
| 瘀血痺阻 | 加乳香 6g、沒藥 6g、雞血藤 15g、桃仁 10g、紅花 6g | 活血化瘀、通絡止痛,用於腰閃扭傷、腰椎間盤病變、腰椎骨質增生偏瘀血者 |
| 腎陽虛甚 | 加仙茅 10g、肉桂 3g(後下)、肉蓯蓉 15g、鹿角膠 10g(烊化)、枸杞子 15g | 溫補腎陽,填精補血,用於骨質疏鬆症或腎病偏腎陽虛者 |
| 腎陰不足 | 去淫羊藿、巴戟天、狗脊、松節,加生地黃 15g、熟地黃 15g、白芍 15g、玄參 12g、山茱萸 10g、雞血藤 15g | 滋陰養血通絡,陰慮火旺者去溫燥之品以防劫陰 |
沈寶藩強調辨證與辨病相結合。同一腰痛,寒溼重者溫散為主,瘀血重者活血為先,腎陽虛甚者峻補命門,腎陰虛者轉為滋陰。陰虛加減法尤其值得注意,原方偏溫燥,陰虛體質用之反助火傷陰,需去溫熱藥改投滋陰,方為穩妥。
小結
補腎壯陽通絡湯以溫補腎陽為主,兼散寒除溼、活血通絡,適合老年腎虛寒溼血瘀型腰痛,尤以腰膝冷痛、遇寒加重、畏寒肢冷者最為對證。方中九味藥補通結合,溫而不燥,陰虛火旺或溼熱腰痛者忌用。
參考文獻:
[1] 沈寶藩.沈寶藩辨證論治老腰痛的經驗[J].中醫臨床研究
[2] 國醫大師沈寶藩經驗方(腰痛/補腎壯陽通絡湯驗方)[J].中醫正骨
[3] 王某,男,65歲,2013年8月5日初診醫案,見沈寶藩老年腰痛驗案